Four years after the model wed the singer's ex, Justin Bieber, and less than two weeks after she delivered a tell-all interview addressing criticism of their relationship, Selena Gomez and Hailey Bieber appeared for their first public images together in an unexpected show of togetherness at Academy Museum Gala in L.A.

On Sunday, October 16, photographer Tyrell Hampton posted a picture of the two on Instagram. He captioned the picture, "Plot twist."